The Divine Command Theory

Right and wrong cannot be defined in basis of Gods willing
Examine and comment on this view.
I agree with the statement that adept and wrong cannot be defined in terms of Gods will it does not make sense to turn to God to divulge out what is right or wrong. The Divine Command speculation states that trust should be the basis of morality. However, I believe that religion does not necessarily lead people to be moral.
Platos Euthyphro dilemma shows that the Divine Command Theory has several problems. If something is estimable simply because God commands it, then God arbitrary He could have given different commands just as easily. jibe to Leibniz, this would be destroying all of Gods love and annulus for why praise him for what he has d unitary if he would be equally praiseworthy in doing exactly the contrary? On the other hand, if God commands something because it is good, then that would mean good is freelance of God. Therefore, we should not follow a God who is arbitrary, precisely preferably, commend about it separately. James Rachels states that we should be autonomous, and think about what is right and wrong for ourselves. Rachels believes it is better to be autonomous because it would be more(prenominal) meaningful.



For example, if someone is donating to charity because they want to help others, it would arguably be more moral than donating to charity simply because a priest told them to. If this is the case, then God is making us do something less(prenominal) moral, and would at that placefore not be worth worshipping. Some whitethorn argue that the outcome of the action is still the same, so there is no difference. Some say that there is a in-between ground between being autonomous and obeying God one could agree with God and do it. However, it is clearly much more meaningful to take an action out of love rather than simply obeying God.
Dawkins states that our sense of morality does not come from religion, but rather, from society and cultural evolution. This provides a more satisfactory account statement of...If you want to get a full essay, order it on our website: Orderessay



If you want to get a full essay, wisit our page: write my essay .